The Truth About Fad Diets: How to Spot Them and Why They Don’t Work

Fad diets have long been luring in unsuspecting individuals interested in losing weight and living healthier. Promising quick fixes and dramatic results, these diets attract people seeking life-changing weight loss and related health benefits. It’s no wonder that fad diets are so widespread. 

As you explore different ways of eating healthier and cutting calories on your weight loss journey, it’s essential to understand what fad diets are, how to spot them, and why they’re far from what they promise to be—because health is anything but a fad.

What Is a Fad Diet?
A fad diet is an eating plan that often becomes popular quickly, thanks to bold claims of fast and significant results. Today, they spread like wildfire through social media, celebrity endorsements, or viral success stories. However, they’re rarely backed by real science or long-term sustainability.

If the diet has one or more of the following characteristics, it might just be a fad diet:

• Promises of Quick Fixes: Many fad diets claim you’ll lose a significant amount of weight within just a few days or weeks (for example, losing 30 pounds in 3 weeks).
• Extreme Calorie Restriction: Diets that drastically reduce your calorie intake, often below 1,200 calories per day, are typically unsustainable. Your body needs a certain number of calories to function correctly, and extreme restriction can lead to nutrient deficiencies and metabolic slowdown. (Use our BMR Calculator to learn how many calories you must eat every day for basic energy needs.)
• One-Size-Fits-All Approach: Fad diets are meant to be sold to as many people as possible, though they rarely take into consideration individual needs, such as age, gender, physical activity level, or health conditions. If a diet feels like it has too many rigid rules to incorporate into your daily life, it’s likely not sustainable.
• Lack of Scientific Evidence: Always check if the diet is supported by reputable scientific research. If it’s based solely on anecdotal evidence or celebrity testimonials, it’s best to steer clear.
• Too Good to Be True: If there’s any universal truth about weight loss, it’s that weight loss is not easy. Sustainable weight loss takes time, and there are no shortcuts. If a diet sounds like it’s offering a miracle solution, it probably is—and you should probably pass

Spotting a fad diet isn’t always easy. However, being able to identify the red flags of fad diets can not only save you from disappointment but also potential health risks. 

5 Reasons Why Fad Diets Don’t Work (for Good)
While fad diets might lead to short-term weight loss, they are rarely effective in the long run. Here’s why:

1. Fad diets can be unsustainable.

Fad diets often require extreme changes to your eating habits that are hard to keep doing over time. Once the diet ends, most people return to their old eating habits, often regaining the weight they lost—and sometimes even more.

2. Fad diets burn out fast.

Fad diets are usually designed for quick results, not long-term health. They don’t teach sustainable habits, such as portion control, balanced nutrition, or mindful eating, which are crucial for maintaining a healthy weight over time.

3. Fad diets can be nutrient-deficient.

Many fad diets eliminate nutrients you need, leading to deficiencies that can affect your energy levels, mood, and overall health. For example, some low-carb diets might deprive your body of necessary fiber, while some low-fat diets can reduce your intake of essential fatty acids.

4. Fad diets may slow you down.

Extreme calorie restriction can slow down your metabolism as your body tries to conserve energy. When you eventually return to normal eating, your slower metabolism can lead to gaining the weight back.

5. Fad diets may impact your relationship with food.

The restrictive nature of fad diets may lead to feelings of deprivation, increased cravings, and a preoccupation with food. This can create an unhealthy relationship with eating and lead to bingeing or emotional eating.

Health Is Not a Trend: What to Do Instead
Instead of falling for the latest fad diet, focus on making sustainable changes to your eating habits. Start by swapping ultra-processed food products for whole foods. Explore established healthy eating plans like the Mediterranean diet, the Keto diet, or a plant-based diet. Eat a balanced diet of foods you love, but practice portion control to help cut calories without sacrificing taste.

If you’re unsure about what healthy eating plan would be right for you, talk to a healthcare provider who can provide personalized advice. While the allure of quick weight loss with a fad diet can be tempting, it’s essential to approach your health with a long-term mindset—making consistent, sustainable, and healthy choices that lead to lasting results.

CON-2182-001 9/24